Quick summary
You can legally refuse the roadside breathalyzer in most cases, but after a DUI arrest, California’s implied consent law (Vehicle Code 23612) requires you to take a breath or blood test. Refusing that test costs you your license for at least 1 year and can add jail time if you are convicted of DUI.
4 key things to know:
- The handheld roadside test (PAS) is optional if you are 21 or older and not on DUI probation.
- Refusing the after-arrest test means a 1-year license suspension (2 or 3 years with priors), with no restricted license.
- Since 2019, the extra jail time applies only if you refuse a breath or urine test, not a blood test.
- You have only 10 days to request a DMV hearing to fight the suspension.
In this article, our California DUI defense lawyers answer 9 common questions about refusing a breathalyzer or other chemical test:
- 1. Can you refuse a breathalyzer in California?
- 2. Roadside test vs. after-arrest test
- 3. Which test do you have to take?
- 4. What counts as a refusal?
- 5. Criminal penalties for refusing
- 6. What happens to your license?
- 7. Can police force a blood test?
- 8. Defenses to a refusal allegation
- 9. Q&A
1. Can you refuse a breathalyzer in California?
Yes, but what happens depends on when you are asked. Before an arrest, the small handheld breath test is usually optional. After a lawful DUI arrest, you have to take a breath or blood test, and refusing it has real costs.
This rule comes from California’s implied consent law, Vehicle Code 23612. By driving in California, you are treated as having already agreed to a chemical test of your blood or breath if you are lawfully arrested for DUI.1
A “chemical test” is a breath, blood or (rarely) urine test that measures the alcohol or drugs in your body. People often call any breath test a “breathalyzer.”
Refusing after arrest is not a separate crime
Refusing the test is not its own criminal charge. Instead, the prosecutor can add a “refusal allegation” to your DUI charge. If you are convicted of DUI and the refusal is proven, the judge must add penalties (see section 5).2 Separately, the DMV suspends your license whether or not you are convicted (see section 6).
2. Roadside test vs. after-arrest test
The two breath tests look alike, but the law treats them very differently. This table shows the difference:
| Test | When it is asked for | Must you take it? | What refusing costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roadside breath test (PAS) | Before arrest | No, if you are 21+ and not on DUI probation | Nothing for most adults; 1-year suspension if under 21 or on DUI probation |
| Breath test | After arrest | Yes | 1-3 year license loss; extra jail or a longer DUI program if convicted |
| Blood test | After arrest | Yes, unless you choose breath | 1-3 year license loss; no extra jail |
| Urine test | After arrest, only if breath and blood aren’t possible | Yes, in those cases | 1-3 year license loss; extra jail if convicted |
The roadside PAS test is usually optional
After you are pulled over but before any arrest, an officer may ask you to blow into a handheld preliminary alcohol screening (PAS) device. The law treats this as a field sobriety test, and the officer must tell you that you have the right to refuse it.3
There is no penalty for refusing the PAS test unless you are under 21 or on DUI probation. For those drivers, refusing it means a 1-year license suspension.4
If you refuse the PAS test, the prosecutor generally can’t use that refusal as evidence of guilt at trial.5 But if you take it, the result can be used to help convict you.6
Example: Maria is pulled over in San Diego and politely declines the handheld breath test. The officer arrests her anyway, and at the station she chooses a breath test and completes it. Maria has not “refused”: declining the roadside test was her right, and the station test satisfied implied consent.
After arrest, the test is required
Once you are lawfully arrested for DUI, implied consent applies. Taking the PAS test earlier does not count; you still have to take the after-arrest test.7
3. Which test do you have to take?
If you are arrested for alcohol DUI, you usually get to choose a breath test or a blood test, and the officer must tell you that you have that choice.8 If you can’t complete the test you chose, you must take the other one.9
Suspected drug DUI
If the officer suspects drugs, you may be asked for a blood test even after a breath test. The officer needs “reasonable cause to believe that a blood test will reveal evidence” that you were under the influence, and must explain the reasons in the report.10
Medical exemptions
People with hemophilia, and people with a heart condition who take a prescribed blood thinner, are excused from the blood test. They must take a urine test instead.11 Fear of needles is not a legal excuse; if you don’t want a blood draw, choose the breath test.
Some conditions, such as acid reflux (GERD) or a keto diet, can affect breath results. They don’t excuse a refusal, but they can be a defense to the result later. See our page on mouth alcohol.
If you are unconscious or hurt
A person who is unconscious, or otherwise unable to refuse, is treated as not having withdrawn consent.12 Even so, a blood draw is a search, so police usually still need a warrant or an emergency. The U.S. Supreme Court has said that when a driver is unconscious, an emergency will usually justify a blood draw without a warrant.13
4. What counts as a refusal?
A refusal is not just saying “no.” Courts have treated all of these as refusals:
- Silence. Not answering when asked to choose a test.
- Conditions. Saying you will test only if your lawyer or doctor is present. You have no right to talk to a lawyer before the test.14
- Not finishing. Starting a breath test but not blowing hard enough on purpose.15
- Changing your mind too late. Officers don’t have to give you a second chance after you refuse.16
A refusal can be excused if an injury, such as a head injury, made you unable to understand or respond, as long as alcohol or drugs didn’t cause the problem.17
We often see refusal reports where the driver was confused, spoke little English or was never clearly asked to choose a test. These details matter, because the officer must give the required warning in a way you can follow (see section 8).
5. Criminal penalties for refusing
If you are convicted of DUI and the prosecutor proves you refused a breath or urine test, the judge must add these penalties:18
| Your DUI | Added penalty for refusing |
|---|---|
| 1st DUI, no injury | No added jail, but the 9-month DUI program instead of the 3-month one19 |
| 1st DUI causing injury | 48 hours in county jail |
| 2nd DUI in 10 years | 96 hours in county jail |
| 3rd DUI in 10 years | 10 days in county jail |
| 4th or later DUI in 10 years | 18 days in county jail |
These penalties come on top of the normal DUI penalties. Our page on Vehicle Code 23578 explains how a refusal can also lead to tougher sentencing.
Refusing a blood test: no added jail since 2019
Since January 1, 2019, these added penalties apply only to refusing a breath or urine test. In the law’s words, they “do not apply to a person who refused to submit to or complete a blood test.”20 A blood-test refusal still costs you your license.
But a blood-test refusal can still hurt you in court. In People v. Bolourchi (2024), a California appeals court held that the jury could be told a refused blood test may show the driver knew he was guilty.21 Jurors in any refusal case may hear this instruction, though a refusal alone can’t prove guilt.22
Example: John is arrested for a first DUI in Sacramento. He agrees to a breath test but refuses a blood draw when the officer later asks for one. If he is convicted, there is no added jail for that refusal, but the DMV can still suspend his license for a year.
Can refusing help your DUI case?
Sometimes. Without a test result, the prosecutor has to rely on the officer’s observations, field sobriety tests and any video. In our experience, prosecutors are often more willing to reduce a DUI with no test result to a lesser charge, or to drop the refusal allegation in a plea deal. Common outcomes include a wet reckless or dry reckless. But you can still be convicted of DUI without a test, and a plea does not undo the DMV’s refusal suspension.
6. What happens to your license?
If you refuse, the DMV will suspend or revoke your license whether or not you are convicted of DUI. How long depends on your prior record in the last 10 years:23
| Priors in 10 years | License action for refusing |
|---|---|
| None | 1-year suspension |
| One prior DUI, wet reckless or refusal/APS suspension | 2-year revocation |
| Two or more | 3-year revocation |
Unlike most DUI suspensions, a refusal suspension comes with no restricted license and no ignition interlock option. DMV’s restricted licenses are available only to drivers who completed a chemical test.24 Compare our page on DUI license suspensions.
What to do in the first 10 days
The officer takes your license and gives you an order that works as a temporary license for 30 days.25 Then:
- Request a DMV hearing within 10 days. If you miss the deadline, the suspension starts automatically. See our page on DMV hearings.
- Keep the order and your paperwork. It is your temporary license.
- Write down what the officer said about the test and the consequences of refusing, as soon as you can.
- Don’t drive after day 30 unless the DMV has put the suspension on hold.
- Talk to a DUI lawyer about both the DMV hearing and the court case.
Your chances at a DMV refusal hearing
Hearings matter. In 2024, about 9.8% of DUI license actions in California involved a refusal, and about 26% of refusal suspensions that went to a hearing were set aside (up from about 19% in 2023), as of DMV’s latest report.26
At the hearing, the DMV looks at whether the officer had reasonable cause to believe you were driving under the influence, whether you were arrested, whether you were properly warned, and whether you refused.27
In our experience, refusal hearings are often won on the warning itself: exactly what the officer said, in what order, and whether you understood it.
The California Supreme Court is also reviewing whether the DMV’s refusal hearings are fair to drivers, in Chi v. Department of Motor Vehicles. The lower court’s 2026 ruling against the driver is not binding while that review is pending.28
If your DUI charge is dropped
The DMV case is separate from the court case. Winning or dropping the criminal case does not automatically end a refusal suspension, and a plea to a lesser charge does not undo it. Ask your lawyer whether the court result can help at the DMV.
7. Can police force a blood test?
Yes, with a warrant. A blood draw is a search under the Fourth Amendment. The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the alcohol leaving your blood over time is not, by itself, an emergency that excuses a warrant.29 It has also held that police can require a breath test after a DUI arrest without a warrant, but not a blood test.30
In practice, officers can often get a warrant quickly, even late at night. In People v. Superior Court (Feghhi) (2026), a California appeals court upheld a blood warrant even though the driver had agreed to a breath test. The court also said a violation of the implied consent statute alone doesn’t get the evidence thrown out.31
If a judge signs a warrant, you have no choice: police can draw your blood in a medically approved way. Physically resisting can lead to new charges.
8. Defenses to a refusal allegation
Being accused of refusing is not the same as losing. Common defenses include:
1) No lawful arrest, or no proof you drove
Implied consent applies only if you were lawfully arrested and actually drove. The California Supreme Court has held that “drove” means the car was moved on purpose.32 If police found you asleep in a parked car, there may be no proof you drove. See our pages on the no-driving defense and lack of probable cause.
Officers usually must see a misdemeanor happen to arrest without a warrant, but DUI has exceptions. For example, they can arrest without seeing you drive if you were in a crash or your car was blocking the road.33
Example: Police find David asleep in his parked car outside a Fresno bar with the engine off. They arrest him, and he refuses a test. If no one saw him drive and nothing shows the car was moved, his lawyer can argue implied consent never applied.
2) You were never warned, or the warning was wrong
Before you refuse, the officer must tell you what refusing will cost: license loss, and a fine and jail for refusing a breath or urine test.34 If the officer never even tried to give that warning, a court can throw out the suspension. In Munro v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2018), an appeals court reversed a suspension for that reason, even though the driver was combative.35
A misleading warning can also be a defense. The California Supreme Court set aside a suspension where the officer said the license “could” be suspended instead of “would.”36
Example: Ana is arrested in Riverside and asks whether refusing matters. The officer shrugs and says she “might” lose her license. She refuses. Because the warning made the penalty sound optional, her lawyer can argue the refusal doesn’t count.
Not every gap in the warning works. A 2021 appeals court held that leaving out the fine-and-jail part did not cancel a DMV suspension, because the DMV wasn’t seeking a fine or jail.37
3) An injury or medical problem, not alcohol
If a head injury, stroke or other medical problem left you unable to understand or answer, your refusal may be excused. This doesn’t work if alcohol or drugs caused the confusion, even prescription drugs you chose to take.38
4) You didn’t understand
If the warning was given in a language you didn’t understand, or you asked questions that were never answered, your lawyer can argue there was no knowing refusal.
5) You weren’t driving a motor vehicle
Implied consent covers motor vehicles. In Beale v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026), a California appeals court reversed a refusal suspension for a man riding an electric bicycle, because an e-bike is not a motor vehicle.39 See Can you get a DUI on a bike?
9. Q&A
Can you refuse a breathalyzer in California?
You can refuse the roadside PAS test if you are 21 or older and not on DUI probation. After a DUI arrest, you must take a breath or blood test; refusing brings a license suspension of 1 to 3 years and can add jail time if you are convicted.
Do you lose your license if you refuse a breathalyzer?
Yes. Refusing the after-arrest test leads to a 1-year suspension, or a 2- or 3-year revocation if you have prior DUIs or refusals in the last 10 years. You can fight it by requesting a DMV hearing within 10 days.
Can you refuse a blood test and take a breath test instead?
Yes. In most alcohol DUI cases you can choose breath or blood. If drugs are suspected, the officer can also ask for a blood test after a breath test.
Is refusing a breathalyzer an admission of guilt?
No. But if you refuse the after-arrest test, the jury may be told it can consider the refusal as a sign you knew you were guilty. A refusal alone can’t prove guilt.
Can a minor refuse a breathalyzer in California?
A driver under 21 who refuses the roadside PAS test faces a 1-year license suspension. Under-21 drivers who refuse the after-arrest test face the same refusal suspension as adults.
Can you talk to a lawyer before taking the test?
No. California law doesn’t give you the right to speak with a lawyer before deciding whether to take the after-arrest test. Insisting on a lawyer first can be treated as a refusal.
If you or a loved one is accused of refusing a chemical test, our California DUI defense lawyers can review the stop, the arrest and the officer’s warning, and help you meet the 10-day DMV deadline. Contact us for a free consultation.
Legal references:
- California Vehicle Code 23612(a)(1)(A) VC: “A person who drives a motor vehicle is deemed to have given his or her consent to chemical testing of his or her blood or breath … if lawfully arrested …”
- California Vehicle Code 23577 VC (as amended by AB 2717, effective January 1, 2019). Subdivision (b): the refusal “shall be pled and proven.” Subdivision (c): “The penalties in this section do not apply to a person who refused to submit to or complete a blood test pursuant to Section 23612.”
- California Vehicle Code 23612(h)-(i) VC: a PAS test “is a field sobriety test,” and the officer must advise the person “of the person’s right to refuse to take the preliminary alcohol screening test.”
- California Vehicle Code 13353.1(a) VC (refusing a PAS test under Vehicle Code 13388 or 13389: 1-year suspension; 2 or 3 years with priors).
- People v. Jackson (2010) 189 Cal.App.4th 1461 (trial court erred by letting the officer testify that the defendant refused the PAS test).
- People v. Bury (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th 1194 (PAS results are admissible to help prove intoxication).
- California Vehicle Code 23612(h)-(i) VC: a PAS test “is a field sobriety test,” and the officer must advise the person “of the person’s right to refuse to take the preliminary alcohol screening test.&rdquo (see note 3 above).
- California Vehicle Code 23612(a)(2)(A) VC: “the person has the choice of whether the test shall be of his or her blood or breath and the officer shall advise the person that he or she has that choice.”
- Kessler v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1992) 9 Cal.App.4th 1134 (a driver who can’t complete one test must choose and complete another).
- California Vehicle Code 23612(a)(2)(C) VC: a person who takes a breath test may also be asked for blood “if the officer has reasonable cause to believe that a blood test will reveal evidence of the person being under the influence.”
- California Vehicle Code 23612(b)-(c) VC: a person “afflicted with hemophilia” or with a heart condition who uses a prescribed anticoagulant “is exempt from the blood test … but shall submit to, and complete, a urine test.”
- California Vehicle Code 23612(a)(5) VC: a person “who is unconscious or otherwise in a condition rendering him or her incapable of refusal is deemed not to have withdrawn his or her consent.”
- Mitchell v. Wisconsin (2019) 588 U.S. 840 (plurality: when a driver is unconscious and can’t take a breath test, exigent circumstances will usually allow a blood draw without a warrant).
- Westmoreland v. Chapman (1968) 268 Cal.App.2d 1 (no right to consult a lawyer before deciding whether to take the test).
- Kessler v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1992) 9 Cal.App.4th 1134 (a driver who can’t complete one test must choose and complete another) (see note 9 above).
- Dunlap v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1984) 156 Cal.App.3d 279 (no duty to give a second chance after a refusal).
- Hughey v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1991) 235 Cal.App.3d 752 (a refusal may be excused when an injury, not alcohol or drugs, left the driver unable to refuse meaningfully).
- California Vehicle Code 23577 VC (as amended by AB 2717, effective January 1, 2019). Subdivision (b): the refusal “shall be pled and proven.” Subdivision (c): “The penalties in this section do not apply to a person who refused to submit to or complete a blood test pursuant to Section 23612.&rdquo (see note 2 above).
- California Vehicle Code 23538(b)(2) VC: a first offender who “refused to take a chemical test” is referred to a licensed program of at least nine months and 60 hours.
- California Vehicle Code 23577 VC (as amended by AB 2717, effective January 1, 2019). Subdivision (b): the refusal “shall be pled and proven.” Subdivision (c): “The penalties in this section do not apply to a person who refused to submit to or complete a blood test pursuant to Section 23612.&rdquo (see note 2 above).
- People v. Bolourchi (2024) 103 Cal.App.5th 243 (CALCRIM 2130 was properly given for a refused warrantless blood test, because the refusal was not punished criminally).
- CALCRIM No. 2130, Refusal—Consciousness of Guilt (Veh. Code, § 23612).
- California Vehicle Code 13353(a) VC (1-year suspension; 2-year revocation with one prior within 10 years; 3-year revocation with two or more).
- California DMV, California Administrative Per Se Facts, 2024 (prepared August 2025): 30-day temporary license; 10 days to request a hearing; restricted licenses require a completed chemical test; refusal rate 9.8% in 2024; 26.28% of .08 refusal actions set aside after hearings in 2024.
- California DMV, California Administrative Per Se Facts, 2024 (prepared August 2025): 30-day temporary license; 10 days to request a hearing; restricted licenses require a completed chemical test; refusal rate 9.8% in 2024; 26.28% of .08 refusal actions set aside after hearings in 2024 (see note 24 above).
- California DMV, California Administrative Per Se Facts, 2024 (prepared August 2025): 30-day temporary license; 10 days to request a hearing; restricted licenses require a completed chemical test; refusal rate 9.8% in 2024; 26.28% of .08 refusal actions set aside after hearings in 2024 (see note 24 above).
- California Vehicle Code 13353(a) VC (1-year suspension; 2-year revocation with one prior within 10 years; 3-year revocation with two or more) (see note 23 above).
- Chi v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 119 Cal.App.5th 473, review granted May 13, 2026 (pending in the California Supreme Court; not binding while review is pending).
- Missouri v. McNeely (2013) 569 U.S. 141 (the natural loss of alcohol from the blood is not by itself an emergency that excuses getting a warrant).
- Birchfield v. North Dakota (2016) 579 U.S. 438 (warrantless breath tests after a DUI arrest are allowed; warrantless blood tests are not, and a state may not make it a crime to refuse one).
- People v. Superior Court (Feghhi) (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 608 (blood warrant upheld even though the driver had agreed to a breath test; a violation of the implied consent statute “does not implicate any constitutional issue or invoke any statutory exclusionary rule”).
- Mercer v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1991) 53 Cal.3d 753 (implied consent applies only to a person who “drove,” meaning volitional movement of the vehicle).
- California Vehicle Code 40300.5 VC (warrantless DUI arrest allowed when, for example, the person “is involved in a traffic crash” or is “observed in or about a vehicle that is obstructing a roadway”).
- California Vehicle Code 23612(a)(1)(A) VC: “A person who drives a motor vehicle is deemed to have given his or her consent to chemical testing of his or her blood or breath … if lawfully arrested …&rdquo (see note 1 above).
- Munro v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 41: the Vehicle Code “requires an arresting officer to at least attempt to provide the required admonition.”
- Decker v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1972) 6 Cal.3d 903 (an admonition that the license “could” be suspended misstated the law; suspension set aside).
- Elmore v. Gordon (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 520 (leaving out the warning about a fine and jail did not invalidate the DMV’s license suspension).
- Hughey v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1991) 235 Cal.App.3d 752 (a refusal may be excused when an injury, not alcohol or drugs, left the driver unable to refuse meaningfully) (see note 17 above).
- Beale v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 782 (license suspension for refusing a blood test reversed for a rider of an electric bicycle, which is not a motor vehicle).