Rare “Auto-Brewery Syndrome” Successfully Used as DUI Defense. Would it Work in San Diego?
There are a large number of defenses and ways to beat DUI charges in San Diego. But a new one may have recently appeared. A rare disorder that causes the body to produce alcohol on its own was recently used to successfully defeat DUI charges in New York state. Would it work in San Diego?
As reported in the Buffalo News, DUI charges against a 35-year-old school teacher were dismissed after her criminal defense attorney proved that she suffered from a rare condition known as “Auto-Brewery Syndrome.”
The teacher had been pulled over and arrested after she registered a .33 percent blood alcohol content – four times the legal limit – even though she had only consumed a few drinks earlier in the day.
Her defense attorney had read about a condition in which the body converts ordinary food into alcohol because of an excessive amount of yeast in the digestive system. He then sent his client to a doctor who diagnosed her with “Auto-Brewery Syndrome” or “Gut Fermentation Syndrome.”
The doctor who gave the diagnosis said he believes that no more than 50 to 100 people have been officially diagnosed with the illness but that at least 95 percent of people who have the condition don’t know they have it because it is so rare and unusual.
The teacher’s case was the first reported case of Auto-Brewery Syndrome being successfully used as a success to DUI charges. Would such a condition – if successfully proven – would work as a defense to San Diego DUI charges is unclear. However, the condition could be analogized to the presence of “mouth alcohol,” which is used as a defense to San Diego DUI charges.
Conditions such as GERD, acid reflux, and heartburn which impact BAC readings by creating “mouth alcohol” are examples of medical DUI defenses. One could argue that a condition in which alcohol is unknowingly and unintentionally present in the body would fit under this kind of defense. But, again, it remains unclear if it actually would.
If you are facing San Diego DUI charges, you need to speak with an attorney immediately. Please give one of our experienced San Diego DUI defense attorneys a call today.
About the Author
A former Los Angeles prosecutor, attorney Neil Shouse graduated with honors from UC Berkeley and Harvard Law School (and completed additional graduate studies at MIT). He has been featured on CNN, Good Morning America, Dr Phil, Court TV, The Today Show and Court TV. Mr Shouse has been recognized by the National Trial Lawyers as one of the Top 100 Criminal and Top 100 Civil Attorneys.
No. A 3rd-time DUI in Colorado causing no serious bodily injury is a traffic misdemeanor carrying 60 days to 1 year of county jail time, $600 to $1,500 in fines plus court costs, a 2-year driver’s license revocation, and 48 to 120 hours of public service. The two prior convictions can be from any state, ...
In an effort to crack down on drunk driving, DUI issues are often reported in the news. Because of this, we all are aware that if we are pulled over for a DUI, we will be called upon to take a breathalyzer test. The breathalyzer machine is touted as being completely accurate, and the final ...
Much of the negotiations between prosecutors and DUI defense attorneys involve reducing a DUI charge to a wet reckless or a dry reckless. Both of these reduced charges fall under California Vehicle Code 23103, the statute defining reckless driving. 1. What is a “wet reckless” in California? A “wet reckless” is a particular form of ...
It depends. Both breath tests and blood tests have pros and cons in Nevada DUI cases. 1. What are the pros and cons of a breath test in Nevada? The advantages of a breath test in a Nevada DUI case are as follows: breathalyzers test only for alcohol, so they will not show if the ...