
Quick summary
At a California DMV hearing after a DUI arrest, the burden of proof is on the DMV, not on you. The DMV must show “by a preponderance of the evidence” (more likely than not) that your license should be suspended, a much lower bar than the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard in criminal court.
3 key things to know:
- The DMV can usually meet its burden with the officer’s sworn report and your test results alone.
- If you show real evidence that the testing rules weren’t followed, the burden shifts back to the DMV to prove the test was reliable anyway.
- The DMV and court cases are separate, but if a jury finds you not guilty, the DMV must reinstate your license.
In this article, our California DUI defense lawyers answer 6 common questions about the burden of proof at a DMV hearing:
- 1. What burden of proof applies?
- 2. What must the DMV prove?
- 3. How does the DMV meet its burden?
- 4. How can you shift the burden back?
- 5. Who decides your case?
- 6. Why can the DMV and court results differ?
- 7. FAQ
1. What burden of proof applies?
At a California DMV hearing after a DUI arrest, the DMV must prove its case “by the preponderance of the evidence.”1 This hearing is called an administrative per se (APS) hearing, and it decides only whether the DMV suspends your driver’s license.
What “preponderance of the evidence” means
A preponderance of the evidence means the facts are more likely true than not. Think of a scale: if the evidence tips it even slightly toward the DMV, the DMV wins.
How that compares to criminal court
In your criminal DUI case, the prosecutor must prove you guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt.”2 That is the highest burden of proof in the law. The DMV’s standard is much lower because a license suspension is a civil matter, not a criminal punishment.
The DMV may use your breath or blood test results and other evidence, such as the officer’s notes on your driving and field sobriety tests, to meet that lower standard.3
2. What must the DMV prove?
The DMV hearing has a short, fixed list of issues.4 For a suspension based on your blood alcohol, the DMV must prove that:
- the officer had reasonable cause to believe you were driving in violation of California’s DUI laws,
- you were placed under arrest, and
- you were driving with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.08% or more (0.04% in a commercial vehicle, 0.05% or 0.01% if you’re under 21, and 0.01% if you’re on probation for DUI).5
If the suspension is for refusing a chemical test, the DMV must instead prove reasonable cause and arrest, that you refused or didn’t finish the test, and that the officer warned you your license would be suspended if you refused.6
What the hearing doesn’t decide
The hearing officer doesn’t decide whether you were “under the influence” or guilty of DUI. That is for the court. The DMV case turns on the BAC number or the refusal.
3. How does the DMV meet its burden?
Usually with paperwork. The DMV puts the arresting officer’s sworn report (form DS 367) and your test results into evidence. Under California law, the officer’s sworn statement of your breath-test result is “sufficient to establish the foundation, even without testimony at the hearing establishing the reliability of the test.”7
In plain terms, the law presumes the officer and the lab did their jobs correctly. The officer often doesn’t testify at all.
You can see and challenge that evidence
You or your lawyer can ask for a copy of the DMV’s evidence at least 10 days before the hearing, testify, cross-examine the DMV’s witnesses, and subpoena your own witnesses and documents.8 To get started, see how to request a DMV hearing within 10 days of your arrest.
4. How can you shift the burden back?
You don’t have to prove you’re innocent. But to overcome the officer’s paperwork, you need affirmative evidence that a testing rule wasn’t followed. A guess or a “maybe” isn’t enough.9
California’s testing rules are in Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations. For example, the officer must watch you for 15 minutes before a breath test to make sure you don’t eat, drink, smoke or burp something up that could skew the result.
Once you show a rule was broken, “the burden then shifts back to the DMV to prove the reliability of the test despite the deviation.”10 If the DMV can’t do that, it loses.
In Myers v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026), a California appeals court agreed that a driver’s suspension had to be set aside because body-camera video showed the officer left the driver alone during the 15-minute observation period. The DMV offered only the officer’s form, so it couldn’t prove the breath test was reliable.11
Example: Maria blows a 0.09% at the station. Her body-camera footage shows the officer stepped away from the patrol car during her 15-minute observation period. At her DMV hearing, her lawyer plays the video. The DMV offers nothing but the officer’s report, so it can’t prove her test was reliable, and her suspension is set aside.
Example: John argues the breath machine “might” have been out of calibration, but he has no records or testimony showing anything was wrong. That’s speculation, so the officer’s report still stands.
In our experience, the officer’s own body-camera video is often the best evidence that the testing rules weren’t followed.

Other common challenges, such as an illegal DUI checkpoint, a stop or arrest without probable cause, or evidence that you weren’t driving, attack the “reasonable cause” and “arrest” issues the DMV must prove. Many of the same DUI defenses work in court too.
5. Who decides your case?
A DMV Driver Safety hearing officer, not a judge, decides your case. Hearings are recorded and held either remotely, by video call, or in person.12
The hearing officer must be neutral. In 2022, a California appeals court held in California DUI Lawyers Assn. v. Department of Motor Vehicles that one hearing officer can’t act as both the DMV’s advocate and the judge.13 In 2024, another court applied that rule where the hearing officer took on the DMV’s role even though no separate DMV advocate appeared.14 The California Supreme Court is now reviewing when a hearing officer’s ties to the DMV create an unfair risk of bias.15
6. Why can the DMV and court results differ?
Because they use different standards and decide different questions. The DMV decision “is a civil matter that is independent of the determination of the person’s guilt or innocence.”16 So you can lose at the DMV and still win your criminal trial, or the reverse.
The two cases are linked in one important way: if you’re acquitted of the DUI charges, the DMV “shall immediately reinstate” a license it suspended after your arrest.17
Example: Luis loses his DMV hearing, and his license is suspended. Months later, a jury finds him not guilty of DUI. The DMV must reinstate his license right away.
The court case carries its own penalties if you’re convicted, such as misdemeanor probation, fines, DUI school, possible jail or work release, a victim impact panel and a separate license suspension, during which an ignition interlock device may let you keep driving. See our guide to first-offense DUI penalties for the details of a first misdemeanor DUI and the criminal court process.
7. FAQ
Who has the burden of proof at a DMV hearing?
The DMV does. It must show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the officer had reasonable cause, that you were arrested, and that your BAC was 0.08% or more (or that you refused a test after being warned).
Can the DMV rely on the police report if the officer doesn’t testify?
Yes. The officer’s sworn report and your test results are presumed valid and can be enough on their own, unless you produce evidence that the testing rules weren’t followed.
What happens to my license if I’m found not guilty in court?
The DMV must immediately reinstate a license it suspended after your arrest.
Why is a DMV hearing harder to win than a criminal trial?
The DMV only has to show its facts are more likely true than not, while a prosecutor must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
If you’ve been arrested for DUI in California, contact our California DUI defense lawyers for a free consultation. We can request your DMV hearing, challenge the officer’s paperwork and fight the criminal case at the same time.
Legal references:
- California Vehicle Code 13557(b)(3) VC: “If the department determines in the review of a determination made under Section 13353.2, by the preponderance of the evidence, all of the following facts, the department shall sustain the order of suspension…”
- California Penal Code 1096 PC: “the effect of this presumption is only to place upon the state the burden of proving him or her guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.”
- Coffey v. Shiomoto (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1198, 1202 (the trial court properly considered, in addition to breath and blood test results, “other circumstantial evidence of intoxication to conclude by a preponderance of the evidence that plaintiff drove with a BAC at or above 0.08 percent”).
- California Vehicle Code 13558(c)(2) VC: “The only issues at the hearing on an order of suspension pursuant to Section 13353.2 shall be those facts listed in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 13557.”
- California Vehicle Code 13557(b)(3) VC (see note 1 above).
- California Vehicle Code 13557(b)(1) VC: “(C) The person refused or failed to complete the chemical test or tests after being requested by a peace officer. (D) … the person had been told that his or her privilege to operate a motor vehicle would be suspended or revoked if he or she refused…”
- Myers v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 470, 480, quoting Manriquez v. Gourley (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 1227, 1233.
- California DMV, “Driver Safety Administrative Hearings Process (FFDL 26)“: “Call to request or submit a written request to review and obtain a copy of DMV’s evidence regarding your case … at least 10 days prior to the date of your hearing”; your rights include to “Testify on your own behalf,” “Cross-examine opposing witnesses” and “Subpoena witnesses and/or documents.”
- Myers v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 470, 480: “Once the DMV presents evidence to establish a prima facie case, the burden shifts to the motorist to produce affirmative evidence of improper performance. … Such a showing … cannot rest on mere speculation. … If such an affirmative showing is made by the motorist that one or more of the requirements of title 17 were not observed, the burden then shifts back to the DMV to prove the reliability of the test despite the deviation.”
- Myers v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 470, 480 (see note 9 above).
- Myers v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 470, 487: “the DMV failed to offer any evidence—by way of officer testimony or otherwise—showing that the tests were reliable despite the videos.”
- California DMV, “Administrative Hearings“: “The hearings are recorded and are conducted remotely or in person. The hearing is held before a Driver Safety Hearing Officer from DMV.”
- California DUI Lawyers Assn. v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th 517, 532.
- Knudsen v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2024) 101 Cal.App.5th 186.
- Romane v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 1002, review granted Aug. 13, 2025, S291093.
- California Vehicle Code 13353.2(e) VC: “The determination of the facts in subdivision (a) is a civil matter that is independent of the determination of the person’s guilt or innocence … If a person is acquitted of criminal charges relating to a determination of facts under subdivision (a) … the department shall immediately reinstate the person’s privilege to operate a motor vehicle if the department has suspended it administratively.”
- California Vehicle Code 13353.2(e) VC (see note 16 above).