Quick summary
A wrongful life lawsuit is a medical malpractice claim brought by a child born with a disability, against a health care provider whose mistake kept the parents from learning about the risk in time to avoid or end the pregnancy. California is one of the few states that allows it, but the child can recover only the extra costs of the condition, not pain and suffering.
- Who sues: The claim belongs to the child, who sues through a parent or other guardian the court appoints. The parents have a separate “wrongful birth” claim.
- What the child can recover: The extra costs caused by the condition, such as special medical care, therapy, education and equipment, for life.
- Deadlines: They’re short: the parents’ claim can expire 1 year after they discover the harm, and the child’s by the 8th birthday.
In this article, our California medical malpractice lawyers answer 10 common questions about wrongful life lawsuits in California:
- 1. What is a wrongful life lawsuit?
- 2. Who can file a wrongful life lawsuit?
- 3. Wrongful life vs. wrongful birth: what’s the difference?
- 4. What does the child have to prove?
- 5. Which conditions can support a claim?
- 6. Who can be sued?
- 7. What compensation can the child recover?
- 8. How long do you have to file?
- 9. Is this the same as a birth defect lawsuit?
- 10. Questions and answers
1. What is a wrongful life lawsuit?
A wrongful life lawsuit is a claim by a child who was born with a serious condition that a doctor, lab or genetic counselor should have warned the parents about. The child argues that, because of the provider’s negligence, the parents never got the chance to avoid the pregnancy or end it.
California courts treat these cases as a form of medical malpractice, usually based on careless genetic counseling or prenatal testing.1 The California Supreme Court first allowed a child to bring this kind of claim in 1982, in Turpin v. Sortini.2
Why the claim is limited
The law does not say that being born is an injury. A court can’t put a dollar value on life with a disability compared with never being born. So the child can’t recover general damages like pain and suffering. What the child can recover are the real, extra costs the condition causes.3

2. Who can file a wrongful life lawsuit?
Only the child can bring a wrongful life claim, but because the child is a minor, someone has to bring it on the child’s behalf.
The child sues through a guardian ad litem
A child can’t file a lawsuit alone. Under California law, a minor appears in court through a guardian or through a “guardian ad litem,” an adult the judge appoints to represent the child in the case.4 In most wrongful life cases, that person is a parent.
The parents have their own claim
The parents can sue in their own names for wrongful birth. Both claims usually go in the same lawsuit. But the parents and the child can’t both recover the same medical expenses.5
What if the parents disagree?
Parents sometimes disagree about whether to sue, or whether to take a settlement. A few rules decide this:
- The judge decides who represents the child. A court can appoint a guardian ad litem whenever it finds that useful, even if the child already has a guardian.6
- Before a lawsuit is filed, either parent may settle the child’s claim if the parents live together. If they live apart, that right belongs to the parent who has custody of the child.7
- Any settlement needs a judge’s approval. A settlement of a child’s claim is not valid until a court approves it, whether or not a lawsuit was filed.8 9
Example: Ana and David are divorced, and Ana has custody of their son. Ana wants to sue the lab that mishandled a prenatal test; David doesn’t. Ana can ask the court to appoint her as her son’s guardian ad litem. If the case settles, a judge must approve the deal before it is final.
What if the child dies?
A claim that survives the child’s death passes to the child’s “successor in interest,” usually the estate.10 The family’s own claim for the child’s death is a separate wrongful death lawsuit.
Who can’t sue
- A healthy child. California courts have never allowed a wrongful life claim by a child born without a physical or mental impairment.11
- A child suing the parents. California law bars any claim against a parent based on the idea that the child should not have been conceived or born.12
3. Wrongful life vs. wrongful birth: what’s the difference?
The difference is who sues: in a wrongful life case the child sues, and in a wrongful birth case the parents sue, over the same medical mistake. Here is how the two claims compare:
| Wrongful life | Wrongful birth | |
|---|---|---|
| Who sues | The child, through a guardian ad litem | The parents |
| What they claim | A provider’s mistake meant the child was born with the condition | A provider’s mistake took away the parents’ choice to avoid or end the pregnancy |
| Damages | Extra costs of the condition only; no pain and suffering | Extra costs of the child’s care; same expense can’t be paid twice |
| Deadline | 3 years from the mistake, or until the 8th birthday if later | 1 year from discovery, 3 years at most |
| Combined? | Yes, both claims are usually brought in one lawsuit | |
Parents may also have a wrongful birth claim when a sterilization or abortion was done carelessly and a pregnancy followed.13 This is sometimes called a “wrongful pregnancy” or “wrongful conception” claim. Our wrongful birth lawsuit page explains the parents’ claim in detail.
Example: Lisa is 2 months pregnant when her obstetrician fails to diagnose her rubella. Her baby is born with congenital rubella, which causes heart defects and deafness. Lisa may bring a wrongful birth claim for the extra costs of her child’s care.
4. What does the child have to prove?
To win a wrongful life case in California, the child must prove 4 things.14

1) The provider missed the risk or failed to warn
The doctor, counselor or lab was careless in one of two ways. Either they failed to diagnose the risk or warn the parents about it, or they failed to do (or offer) a test that would have shown the risk.
In a testing case, there must be at least a 50% chance the test would have found the condition. In one California case, a 20% chance was not enough.15
2) The child was born with the condition
The child must actually have been born with the impairment, and it must cause a physical or mental disability.16
3) The parents would have avoided or ended the pregnancy
The child must show that, if the parents had known, the mother would not have become pregnant or would not have continued the pregnancy.
4) The mistake caused extra costs
The provider’s negligence must be a substantial factor in causing the extra expenses of caring for the child.
Example: Maria and John take their first daughter to a specialist for hearing loss. The specialist never tells them her deafness is hereditary. They have a second child, who is born with the same total deafness. The second child may bring a wrongful life claim for the extra cost of hearing equipment and special schooling.

5. Which conditions can support a claim?
Any condition that causes a physical or mental disability and that proper testing or counseling would have revealed can support a claim. Courts have allowed claims involving:
- Hereditary deafness, in Turpin v. Sortini.17
- Tay-Sachs disease, in Curlender v. Bio-Science Laboratories.18
- Spina bifida and hydrocephalus, in Gami v. Mullikin Medical Center, where a blood sample for a prenatal screening test couldn’t be used and nobody asked the mother for a second one.19
- Down syndrome, in Andalon v. Superior Court.20
These conditions are often found through prenatal tests such as ultrasound, blood screening and amniocentesis, or through genetic carrier testing of the parents before pregnancy.

What isn’t enough
- Being born healthy. A child born without an impairment has no wrongful life claim.21
- Being born out of wedlock. A court rejected a claim by a healthy child born after a failed abortion who argued the illegitimate birth itself was the harm.22
- Being born to a parent who can’t provide care. A court rejected claims by a healthy child born to a mother living in a mental health facility.23
6. Who can be sued?
Any health care provider whose careless counseling or testing caused the loss can be a defendant. That includes:
- obstetricians, perinatologists and family doctors,
- genetic counselors,
- testing labs, and
- sperm banks and fertility clinics, which a California court has treated as health care providers.24
A clinic or hospital can also be responsible for mistakes its employees make on the job, under the rule of vicarious liability.25
7. What compensation can the child recover?
The child can recover “special damages”: the extra expenses the condition causes, now and for the rest of the child’s life.26 These include:
- past and future medical bills, treatment, therapy and prescriptions,
- special education and training,
- equipment such as wheelchairs and hearing aids, and non-medical care, and
- home changes to fit the child’s needs.
How these costs are proven
Because the costs run for a lifetime, they are usually proven with a life care plan and testimony from medical and financial experts. In our experience, a detailed life care plan is often the most important evidence in these cases, because it turns the child’s needs into a number a jury can follow.
What the child can’t recover
The child can’t recover general (non-economic) damages such as pain and suffering or emotional distress.27 The child also can’t recover lost earning capacity.28 29 Claims like loss of consortium don’t apply to the child’s claim either. Learn more about the types of damages in California injury cases and the difference between general and special damages.
Medi-Cal liens on a settlement
If Medi-Cal paid for the child’s care, the state can claim part of a wrongful life settlement. In Daniel C. v. White Memorial Medical Center (2022), a California appeals court held that the state’s lien reaches only the part of the settlement for past medical expenses, not money for future care or other damages.30
8. How long do you have to file?
Under California’s malpractice deadline, the child generally has 3 years from the provider’s mistake to file, or until the 8th birthday if that is later. The parents’ own claim must be filed within 1 year after they discover the harm, and never more than 3 years after it.31

Fraud or intentional concealment by the provider can extend these deadlines.32 Read more about the medical malpractice statute of limitations in California.
Example: In Gami, the parents waited too long and their own claim was thrown out under the 1-year rule. Their daughter’s wrongful life claim, filed in her name, was allowed to go forward.33
One thing we often see is families who wait until the child’s needs are clear before talking to a lawyer. By then, the parents’ 1-year deadline may already have passed.
9. Is this the same as a birth defect lawsuit?
Not exactly. “Birth defect lawsuit” can mean 3 different kinds of cases:
- Missed-diagnosis claims (wrongful life and wrongful birth): a provider failed to warn the parents about a condition the child already had or was at risk for.
- Birth injuries: a doctor’s mistake during pregnancy or delivery caused the injury itself. These are ordinary medical malpractice cases, and the child can recover pain and suffering.
- Drug or chemical exposure: a medication or toxic exposure caused the defect. These are usually product liability or mass tort claims.
Exposure claims against someone other than a doctor follow different rules. In Elsheref v. Applied Materials, a California appeals court held that an employer owed no duty to a child whose birth defects were blamed on the father’s chemical exposure at work before the pregnancy.34 For claims based on recklessness or a dangerous product, a different analysis applies.
10. Questions and answers
What is the difference between wrongful life and wrongful birth?
A wrongful life claim is brought by the child; a wrongful birth claim is brought by the parents. Both are based on the same medical mistake and are usually brought together.
Can a child sue for being born?
In California, a child born with a disability can sue a health care provider whose negligence kept the parents from avoiding the pregnancy. The child can recover only the extra costs of the condition, and a healthy child has no claim.
Can a child sue their parents for being born?
No. California Civil Code 43.6 bars any claim against a parent based on the idea that the child should not have been conceived or born.
Who files the lawsuit for the child?
A parent or other adult whom the court appoints as guardian ad litem. A judge must approve any settlement of the child’s claim.
How long do you have to file a wrongful life lawsuit in California?
The child generally has 3 years from the provider’s mistake, or until age 8 if that is later. The parents’ claim can expire 1 year after they discover the harm.
What damages can the child recover?
The extra lifetime costs of the condition, such as medical care, therapy, special education and equipment. Pain and suffering and lost earnings are not recoverable.
Call us for help
If your child was born with a condition a doctor, lab or genetic counselor should have warned you about, our California personal injury attorneys can review your case in a free consultation. Contact us to talk about your family’s options and deadlines.
Legal references:
- Gami v. Mullikin Medical Center (1993) 18 Cal.App.4th 870, 883: “Claims for ‘wrongful life’ are essentially actions for malpractice based on negligent genetic counseling and testing.”
- Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220, 239: A child “may not recover general damages for being born impaired as opposed to not being born at all,” but “may recover special damages for the extraordinary expenses necessary to treat the hereditary ailment.”
- Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220, 239 (see note 2 above).
- California Code of Civil Procedure 372(a)(1): A minor “shall appear either by a guardian or conservator of the estate or by a guardian ad litem appointed by the court in which the action or proceeding is pending.”
- Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220, 238: “[T]he parents and child cannot, of course, both recover for the same medical expenses.”
- California Code of Civil Procedure 372(a)(2)(A): A guardian ad litem may be appointed “when it is deemed by the court … expedient,” even if the minor already has a guardian.
- California Probate Code 3500(a)–(b): Either parent may compromise a minor’s claim if the parents live together, or “the parent having the care, custody, or control of the minor” if they live apart; the compromise “is valid only after it has been approved” by the superior court.
- California Probate Code 3500(a)–(b) (see note 7 above).
- California Code of Civil Procedure 372(a)(3): The guardian ad litem may compromise the claim “with the approval of the court in which the action or proceeding is pending.”
- California Code of Civil Procedure 377.30: “A cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding passes to the decedent’s successor in interest….”
- Alexandria S. v. Pacific Fertility Medical Center, Inc. (1997) 55 Cal.App.4th 110, 122: “No court, however, has expanded tort liability to include wrongful life claims by children born without any mental or physical impairment.”
- California Civil Code 43.6(a): “No cause of action arises against a parent of a child based upon the claim that the child should not have been conceived or, if conceived, should not have been allowed to have been born alive.”
- CACI 511 (Wrongful Birth—Sterilization/Abortion—Essential Factual Elements)
- CACI 513 (Wrongful Life—Essential Factual Elements)
- Simmons v. West Covina Medical Clinic (1989) 212 Cal.App.3d 696, 702–703: “A less than 50-50 possibility that defendants’ omission caused the harm does not meet” the reasonable medical probability test.
- CACI 513 (Wrongful Life—Essential Factual Elements) (see note 14 above).
- Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220, 239 (see note 2 above).
- Curlender v. Bio-Science Laboratories (1980) 106 Cal.App.3d 811 (disapproved in part on damages by Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220)
- Gami v. Mullikin Medical Center (1993) 18 Cal.App.4th 870, 874: The blood sample for alpha-fetoprotein testing “proved unsuitable for testing,” and no one “advised Raksha to provide a second sample.”
- Andalon v. Superior Court (1984) 162 Cal.App.3d 600, 614: “The merits of the plaintiff-child’s claim for loss of earning capacity are controlled by the reasoning in Turpin….”
- Alexandria S. v. Pacific Fertility Medical Center, Inc. (1997) 55 Cal.App.4th 110, 122 (see note 11 above).
- Stills v. Gratton (1976) 55 Cal.App.3d 698, 705
- Foy v. Greenblott (1983) 141 Cal.App.3d 1
- Johnson v. Superior Court (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 869
- California Civil Code 2338: “[A] principal is responsible to third persons for the negligence of his agent in the transaction of the business of the agency….”
- Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220, 239 (see note 2 above).
- Turpin v. Sortini (1982) 31 Cal.3d 220, 239 (see note 2 above).
- Andalon v. Superior Court (1984) 162 Cal.App.3d 600, 614 (see note 20 above).
- Daniel C. v. White Memorial Medical Center (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 789: A wrongful life plaintiff “may not recover for lost earnings or general damages, including pain and suffering”; the Medi-Cal lien attaches only to the part of the settlement for past medical expenses (Welf. & Inst. Code 14124.76).
- Daniel C. v. White Memorial Medical Center (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 789 (see note 29 above).
- California Code of Civil Procedure 340.5: “Actions by a minor shall be commenced within three years from the date of the alleged wrongful act except that actions by a minor under the full age of six years shall be commenced within three years or prior to his eighth birthday whichever provides a longer period.”
- California Code of Civil Procedure 340.5 (see note 31 above).
- Gami v. Mullikin Medical Center (1993) 18 Cal.App.4th 870, 873, 883
- Elsheref v. Applied Materials, Inc. (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 451