Quick summary
HOA fraud in California covers crimes committed in connection with a homeowners or condominium association, usually by board members. Common charges include embezzlement of association funds (Penal Code 503), falsifying the association’s books, rigging board elections and taking kickbacks.
- Penalties: Embezzling more than $950 is grand theft, a wobbler punishable by up to 3 years. Falsifying records is also a wobbler, and mail or wire fraud can bring up to 20 years in federal prison.
- Defenses: Most HOA fraud charges require intent to defraud, so honest mistakes and lack of intent are strong defenses.
- Example: A treasurer moves HOA money to a safer bank in the HOA’s own name. Because she didn’t take it for herself, that isn’t embezzlement.
An increasing number of Californians live in condominiums, townhouses or houses that are governed by a homeowners association (an “HOA“) or a condominium association (a “COA”). As of 2025, an estimated 14.5 million Californians lived in about 51,700 community associations, more than in any other state.1
According to a 1998 state report, in some areas of California, like Orange County and San Diego County, most new housing built since around the 1980s has been part of a common interest development.2
Homeowners association fraud (also called HOA fraud or condominium association fraud) describes white-collar crimes committed in connection with an HOA or COA.
People accused of HOA fraud and corruption are generally members of an HOA or COA board. Serving on one of these boards can be a thankless job even under normal circumstances. It’s usually an unpaid, time-consuming position. Other homeowners and condo owners tend to blame board members for everything that goes wrong and may try to turn a personal or political dispute into a legal matter.3 For board members, accusations that they have committed HOA fraud can feel like insult added to injury.
In this article, our California criminal defense attorneys explain the crime of HOA fraud and corruption in California by addressing the following:
- 1. How homeowner associations and condominium associations work
- 2. Common types of HOA fraud
- 3. Legal defenses
If you would like more information after reading this article, we invite you to contact us at Shouse Law Group.
1. How homeowner associations and condominium associations work
1.1. History of HOAs and COAs
If you own your own single-family home on its own lot and don’t share community facilities with your neighbors, then you probably don’t have to deal with an HOA or COA.
But a large number of homeowners live in a “common interest development.” This means that they may own
- a condominium,
- a townhouse, or
- a single-family house that is part of a larger planned development (sometimes called a “gated community”) with common recreational facilities — like a swimming pool or outdoor space.
These homeowners have space that only they own-like the inside of their condo unit or their own private house. But they also own certain space-like the lobby or hallways of the condominium, or the shared recreational facilities-in common with other homeowners in the condo or community.4
Up until about the 1960s, only fairly well-off people tended to live in common interest developments. But since then, the number of these developments has skyrocketed. A 1998 state report found that most new housing in California was then being built in these communities.
A lot of growth in common interest developments took place in the 1980s. Local governments in California were collecting a lot less in taxes thanks to recent policy reforms and so couldn’t pay for amenities like parks and streets for new housing. But common interest developments stepped in to fill the gap by building and managing these kinds of amenities themselves.5
In 1985, the California Legislature passed the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, which sets detailed rules for how these communities are run. The Act was reorganized and renumbered in 2014 and is now found at Civil Code 4000 and following sections.6
1.2. HOA and COA governance
Simply put, if you own a condo, townhouse, or house that is part of a gated community or other common interest development, then you are a member of either a condominium association (COA) or a homeowner association (HOA). In theory, the HOA or COA manages the community of which your home is a part.7
But in practice, most important decisions about the management of the community are made by a smaller group of homeowners who serve on the HOA board of directors.8
The board members are elected by the whole group of homeowners.9 They control the budget of the condo building or residential community. For example, the board members decide how much to spend on maintaining or repairing the common areas. They may also decide how much money to collect from the other homeowners through so-called “assessments.”10
According to Los Angeles and Pasadena criminal defense attorney Neil Shouse:
“It can be helpful to think of an HOA (or COA) board as being sort of like a mini- government. Like a government, it has the power to collect taxes (though in this case they are called assessments) and then to decide how to spend that money. Just like with regular governments, this power leads to lots of room for controversy and sometimes even corruption and fraudulent activity.”
HOA board members are usually the ones accused of HOA fraud, often after they take actions that other homeowners disagree with. HOA fraud is a nonviolent financial crime, but a conviction can still bring steep penalties and serious personal and professional consequences.
2. Common types of HOA fraud
2.1. Embezzlement (Penal Code 503)
California embezzlement laws define embezzlement as the act of fraudulently taking for yourself property that has been entrusted to you by someone else.11Embezzlement in the HOA or COA context would consist of an HOA or COA board member somehow diverting the HOA or COA’s money to himself or herself. This is a form of HOA fraud.
Example: Betty owns a condo in a building called Woodbridge Estates. She is elected to the board of the Woodbridge Estates COA, and she is named the treasurer of the board. Because of this, she is given control over the COA’s bank account, and she also maintains the COA’s financial records.
Every month, Betty transfers $1000 from the COA’s bank account to her own personal account. She does not record these transfers on the COA’s financial records, so no one else knows about them. Betty has committed embezzlement.
Elements of embezzlement
In order to convict you of embezzlement from an HOA or COA, a county district attorney or state attorney general would have to show four things:
- That the HOA entrusted property to you (for example, by giving you the right to access HOA money),
- That the HOA did so because it put trust in you (this could be shown by your election to the board, or your being given a position on the board that gave you access to HOA funds),
- That you fraudulently took the property for your own benefit, and
- That you intended to deprive the HOA of the property.12
Example: Terry is a board member of the HOA for the planned community where he lives. The HOA keeps its money in a small local bank that is having financial troubles. Terry begins to worry that the bank may fail. So he transfers the HOA’s funds to a new account at his own bank, which is bigger and more stable. Terry is probably not guilty of HOA embezzlement. He didn’t move the money for his own benefit but instead took it for the HOA’s benefit. Also, he did not intend to deprive the HOA of its property. He is not an embezzler.
Intent to restore is not a defense
In California, you can be convicted of embezzlement even if you only meant to borrow the HOA’s money. If you haven’t returned the property by the time you are formally charged, the fact that you planned to give it back is not a defense.13
Example: Maria is a single mother and a condo owner. She is a member of the board of her COA. One month, she is faced with high medical bills for one of her children. She cannot pay them when they are due but knows she will be able to pay them in a few months, when she will get a tax refund.
Maria transfers money from the COA’s bank account to her own bank account and uses it to pay the medical bills. Her plan is to refund the money when her tax refund arrives. But she is arrested and charged with the COA fraud crime of embezzlement before she can do so. She can still be found guilty even though she intended to give the money back.
Penalties
Under California law, embezzlement is a form of theft.14 The potential penalties depend on how much money or property was embezzled.
If the value of the property taken is more than nine hundred fifty dollars ($950), it is grand theft.15 Grand theft is a “wobbler” in California law, which means that it may be prosecuted as either a misdemeanor or a felony in California law.16 The prosecutor will decide whether to bring misdemeanor or felony charges based on the circumstances of your case and your criminal history.
If you are charged with grand theft as a misdemeanor, you may be sentenced to up to one (1) year in county jail.17 If felony charges are brought, you may be imprisoned for sixteen (16) months or two (2) or three (3) years.18
But if the value of the property embezzled is $950 or less, HOA fraud through embezzlement is a form of petty theft.19 Petty theft is a misdemeanor. The possible penalties are a fine of up to one thousand dollars ($1,000), up to six (6) months in county jail, or both.20
2.2. Corporate law violations
Another form of HOA fraud consists of violations of California corporate law.
This is because HOAs and COAs are usually California corporations.21 Specifically, they are usually a kind of California nonprofit corporation known as a “mutual benefit corporation.”22
Directors of a mutual benefit corporation like an HOA or COA can face criminal penalties if they commit certain misconduct in connection with their duties. These include:
- Lying about the HOA’s financial condition;23
- Seriously exaggerating about the HOA’s operations or financial condition;24
- Taking possession of any property of the corporation while failing to make an entry of this in the HOA’s books;25 and
- Destroying or fabricating any of the records of the HOA with intent to defraud (for example, “cooking the books”).26
Examples
Example: The HOA of Broke Estates, a planned community, is running out of money. It may not have enough funds left to pay for landscaping and other essential services in a few months.
The members of the board of directors of Broke Estates know this. But they don’t want the other homeowners to know, because they are afraid that if they do know, they will stop paying their assessments. This will make matters even worse financially. So the board sends the other homeowners a report that claims the HOA has much more money in reserves than it actually does.
The board members are probably guilty of HOA fraud for lying about its financial condition.
Example: Dave is a member of the board of directors of his condo, Corruption Towers. His brother-in-law Carter is a contractor.
Dave is given the task of finding a contractor to make some necessary repairs to Corruption Towers. He gets five bids from several companies, including Carter’s. Three of the bids are lower than Carter’s bid, but Dave wants to give Carter the business. So he shreds the three written bids that were lower than Carter’s…and awards the vendor contract to Carter.
Dave is probably guilty of COA fraud for destroying COA records with intent to defraud the COA (by forcing it to pay more for the repairs than it needed to).
Penalties
This form of HOA fraud is a wobbler, so it may be prosecuted as either a misdemeanor or a felony. It is punishable by state prison (16 months, 2 or 3 years), up to 1 year in county jail, and/or a fine of up to $1,000.27
2.3. Rigging elections
One particularly complicated form of HOA fraud is rigging elections to HOA and COA boards. The way this works is that people band together to get their friends and associates elected to boards. Those people then use their power as board members to steer contracts to companies they own or skim funds from the HOA.28
In one especially large scheme prosecuted in federal court in Nevada, in which 26 people pleaded guilty, a group of conspirators gained control of COA boards for a number of condo complexes in several ways, such as:
- Paying people to purchase empty condos with funds provided by the defendants, and
- Forging ballots for condo owners who lived out of town and were unlikely to vote themselves.
Once they controlled the boards of these condos, the defendants would steer contracts for expensive services to a particular law firm, construction company and property managers working with them.29
Penalties
This form of HOA or COA fraud can be prosecuted in several ways. If the people involved use the mail or any form of wire communication (telephone, email, etc.) to advance the scheme, then the federal government may charge them with the federal crimes of mail fraud, wire fraud in California, or both.30
Federal mail and wire fraud each carry up to 20 years in federal prison, a fine, or both (up to 30 years if the fraud affects a financial institution).31
Rigging the election of a corporate board can also be a California state crime. California corporate law makes it a crime for a director of a mutual benefit corporation to knowingly issue a membership in the corporation for the purpose of defrauding current members.32 Arranging for people to buy units solely for the purpose of casting certain votes could make one guilty of this crime.
This crime is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year in county jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both.
Finally, forging ballots could be a violation of California forgery laws. Forgery is the crime of signing someone else’s name without permission or falsifying certain important documents, in a way that deprives someone else of their property or legal rights.33
Forgery is a wobbler, so it may be prosecuted as either a misdemeanor or a felony.34 As a misdemeanor, it carries up to 1 year in county jail. As a felony, it carries 16 months, 2 or 3 years under Penal Code 1170(h). Forgery of a check or similar instrument worth $950 or less is generally a misdemeanor only.35
2.4. Kickbacks / steering contracts
Another common form of HOA fraud is the practice of steering contracts to a board member’s friends or associates, usually in connection with so-called “kickbacks.” A “kickback” occurs when someone returns a portion of the money they’ve received to someone else in order to receive a benefit they should not be receiving.36
Example: Barry gets elected to the board of the HOA for his townhome community. The HOA needs to hire a new accountant to audit its financial records.
Barry’s friend Adam is an accountant just starting his own practice. Adam tells Barry that if Barry can persuade the other board members to hire him, he will give 25% of his profits from the work back to Barry. Barry agrees.
This is a kickback, and Barry may have committed HOA fraud.
This kind of kickback scheme can lead to federal charges for mail fraud and/or wire fraud, as long as the defendants used the mail or any kind of wire communication in forming or carrying out their scheme.37 It could also lead to California commercial bribery charges. Commercial bribery is a misdemeanor if the bribe is $1,000 or less and a wobbler if it is more than $1,000. The law does not apply to bribes of $250 or less.38
3. Legal defenses
3.1. Lack of intent
Most of the criminal charges that can be filed against someone who commits HOA fraud require that the defendant intended to commit fraud.
For example, the California crime of embezzlement requires specific intent to deprive the owner of the embezzled property.39 The federal crimes of mail fraud and wire fraud require specific intent to defraud a third party.40 The California crime of forgery also requires intent to defraud.41
This means you cannot be convicted of these crimes unless the prosecutor proves, beyond a reasonable doubt, that you acted with the required intent to defraud or to deprive someone of their property.
Proving intent means convincing the jury of what you were thinking at the time, which can be hard to do. For this reason, lack of intent can be a powerful legal defense to charges of HOA or COA fraud.
3.2. Mistake of fact
The well-known legal defense of mistake of fact can also be helpful in fighting California HOA fraud charges.
Because you generally need to have intended to commit fraud, or have known what you were doing, to be convicted of HOA fraud, you may be able to beat charges if you can show that you were simply mistaken about a key fact. Many innocent facts can be misconstrued as traditional warning signs or red flags of HOA frauds.
In our experience, many HOA fraud cases involve volunteer board members who made honest mistakes while handling complicated financial and business matters outside their expertise.
In any case, common evidence in these cases include:
- bookkeeper records
- CPA records
- financial documents / financial statements
- bank statements
- credit card statements
- reimbursement records
- HOA management company documents
- HOA governing documents
If prosecutors cannot prove beyond a reasonable doubt that any discrepancies were due to fraud rather than error, you should not be convicted.
For additional help…
If you or a loved one is charged with HOA fraud and corruption and you are looking to hire an attorney for representation, we invite you to contact us at Shouse Law Group. We can provide a free consultation in office or by phone. We have offices throughout California.
For information on Nevada HOA Fraud laws, read our article on Nevada HOA Fraud laws.
Legal references:
- Foundation for Community Association Research, 2025 U.S. National and State Statistical Review (California: about 51,700 associations and 14,489,000 residents in 2025).
- Helen E. Roland, Residential Common Interest Developments: An Overview (California Research Bureau, March 1998), at 2.
- Helen E. Roland, Residential Common Interest Developments: An Overview (California Research Bureau, March 1998), at 27 (“Members of CID boards do not receive compensation. The time commitment can be substantial. The job can seem thankless.”).
- Helen E. Roland, Residential Common Interest Developments: An Overview (California Research Bureau, March 1998), at 1.
- Helen E. Roland, Residential Common Interest Developments: An Overview (California Research Bureau, March 1998), at 3-6.
- California Civil Code 4000 and following sections (Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act; operative January 1, 2014).
- California Civil Code 4080 (“‘Association’ means a nonprofit corporation or unincorporated association created for the purpose of managing a common interest development.”); Civil Code 4800 (“A common interest development shall be managed by an association that may be incorporated or unincorporated.”).
- California Corporations Code 7210 (“Each corporation shall have a board of directors.”).
- California Civil Code 5100 (secret-ballot elections for directors).
- Helen E. Roland, Residential Common Interest Developments: An Overview (California Research Bureau, March 1998), at 21-22.
- California Penal Code 503: “Embezzlement is the fraudulent appropriation of property by a person to whom it has been intrusted.”
- CALCRIM No. 1806, Theft by Embezzlement.
- California Penal Code 512: “The fact that the accused intended to restore the property embezzled, is no ground of defense or mitigation of punishment, if it has not been restored before an information has been laid before a magistrate, or an indictment found by a grand jury, charging the commission of the offense.” See also CALCRIM No. 1806 (see note 12 above) (“Intent to restore the property to its owner is not a defense.”).
- California Penal Code 484(a) (theft includes fraudulently appropriating property entrusted to you).
- California Penal Code 487(a) (grand theft when the value exceeds $950).
- California Penal Code 489(c)(1) (county jail up to 1 year or imprisonment under Penal Code 1170(h)); Penal Code 17(b) (wobblers).
- Penal Code 489(c)(1) (see note 16 above).
- California Penal Code 1170(h)(1) (16 months, 2 or 3 years).
- California Penal Code 488 (“Theft in other cases is petty theft.”).
- California Penal Code 490 (fine up to $1,000, up to 6 months in county jail, or both).
- Civil Code 4080 (see note 7 above).
- Helen E. Roland, Residential Common Interest Developments: An Overview (California Research Bureau, March 1998), at 21.
- California Corporations Code 8813(a)(1).
- Corporations Code 8813(a)(2) (see note 23 above).
- California Corporations Code 8814(a).
- Corporations Code 8814(b) (see note 25 above).
- Corporations Code 8813(c) (see note 23 above) and 8814(c) (see note 25 above); Penal Code 18 (felony term of 16 months, 2 or 3 years).
- U.S. Department of Justice, Criminal Division, “HOA Cases” (scheme to fraudulently control Las Vegas-area condominium HOAs; 26 people pleaded guilty).
- U.S. Department of Justice, “Fourteen Defendants Plead Guilty for Their Roles in Scheme to Fraudulently Control Home Owners Associations in Las Vegas”.
- 18 U.S.C. § 1341 (mail fraud); 18 U.S.C. § 1343 (wire fraud).
- 18 U.S.C. §§ 1341, 1343 (see note 30 above) (up to 20 years; up to 30 years and $1,000,000 if the violation affects a financial institution or involves disaster benefits).
- California Corporations Code 8811 (misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to $1,000, up to 1 year in county jail, or both).
- California Penal Code 470.
- California Penal Code 473(a).
- Penal Code 473(a)-(b) (see note 34 above); Penal Code 1170(h) (see note 18 above).
- Black’s Law Dictionary (9th ed. 2009), “kickback.”
- 18 U.S.C. §§ 1341, 1343 (see note 30 above); 18 U.S.C. § 1346 (scheme to deprive another of the intangible right of honest services).
- California Penal Code 641.3(b)-(c).
- CALCRIM No. 1806 (see note 12 above).
- 18 U.S.C. §§ 1341, 1343 (see note 30 above).
- People v. Neder (1971) 16 Cal.App.3d 846 (the essence of forgery is signing another’s name or falsely making a document “with intent to defraud”).