Posted on
In limited circumstances, you can sue your employer if you have been hurt on the job. Generally speaking, however, workers’ compensation is the exclusive remedy.
You may be able to sue your employer if the employer
- intentionally causes the injury,
- fraudulently conceals their connection to the injury,
- acts in a dual capacity,
- or does not carry workers’ compensation insurance.
In this article, we will explain each of these scenarios.
You may also be able to file a personal injury lawsuit against a third party who was responsible for your injuries suffered on the job.
Can I sue my employer for a workplace injury?
Generally, if you have suffered a workplace injury, you will have to file a workers’ compensation claim to cover your injuries. This is called the exclusive remedy rule.
However, depending on the state, there are 4 important exceptions that may apply to this rule. If one is in play, you can sue your employer, rather than collect workers’ compensation. These exceptions are when the employer:
- intentionally caused the injury,
- fraudulently concealed the injury or its connection to the workplace,
- hurt you in a different capacity than as your employer, or
- does not carry workers’ compensation insurance.
Additionally, you may be able to file a personal injury claim against someone other than their employer if you were hurt on the job by a third party.
Pursuing a tort claim outside of the workers’ compensation system has its pros and cons:
- a personal injury claim can recover a wider variety of legal damages, but
- workers’ compensation claims do not require you to prove that the employer was negligent or culpable.
Compensation/Damages
The compensation that is available is very important. When you file a workers’ comp claim, you can receive:
- medical benefits, including payment of medical expenses, and
- disability benefits to cover at least a portion of their lost wages.
However, by filing a personal injury claim you can potentially recover full compensation that covers all of your:
- medical bills,
- lost wages,
- reduced earning capacity, if the injury will cause long-term professional difficulties,
- pain and suffering,
- loss of consortium, and potentially
- punitive damages.
Pursuing your claim as a personal injury lawsuit rather than as a workers’ compensation case can ensure that you recover full compensation for your job injury. The legal advice of a personal injury lawyer or workers’ compensation attorney can help you make an informed decision about what to do next.
Intentional injuries
Workers’ compensation laws are designed to cover your losses for accidents that happen on the job. If an employer intentionally hurts you, it was not an accident. You can file a personal injury lawsuit against your employer, rather than a workers’ compensation claim.
These injuries are often the result of an employer’s:
State laws differ
In some states, the employer can be liable in a personal injury lawsuit if it
- ratifies,
- approves of,
- commands, or
- authorizes the infliction of injuries on you by a coworker or supervisor.1
Some states hold employers liable for knowingly removing or failing to install safety guards on heavy machinery.2 In a few states, you can hold your employer liable for workplace injuries caused by less than intentional conduct.
Some states extend the exception for an employer’s intentional actions to include conduct that is “deliberate.”3 Still others let you sue your employers if the employer’s unintentional conduct was “substantially certain to cause injury.”4
A couple of states require the employer to act with knowledge that an injury was virtually certain to occur.5 However, lots of states still refuse to allow personal injury claims against an employer for conduct that was not strictly intentional.6
No state allows these claims to proceed if they are based on the employer’s negligence.
Fraudulent concealment
You may also be able to sue your employers if the employer fraudulently conceals the injury. This often involves a disease or illness due to toxins in the workplace. While the underlying illness will be covered by workers’ compensation, you can take your employer to court for fraudulently concealing the problem from them.7
Not all states allow victims of fraudulent concealment to get around the exclusive remedy of workers’ comp. Many states still require you to go through the regular workers’ compensation process.
You may be able to sue your boss for a work injury if you were injured outside of work.
Dual capacity
In some cases, employers interact with you in a dual capacity; both as an employer and as something else. In some states, if you are hurt by your employer outside of the employment context, you can sue your employer without going through the workers’ compensation system.8
Some examples of employers interacting with an employee in a capacity other than as an employer include:
- owning the premises where you slipped and fell,
- acting as a vendor in the workplace, like operating a cafeteria for workers,
- providing negligent medical care to you when you were already hurt in a workplace accident, and
- hurting you when you use a product that was defectively manufactured by the employer.
Many states limit which dual capacities can lead to a personal injury lawsuit.9 Some states do not allow lawsuits based on dual capacity, at all.10
No workers’ compensation insurance
Perhaps the most common way for you to sue your employer for a workplace injury is if the employer does not provide workers’ compensation coverage. This can happen if:
- the employer is not legally required to carry workers’ compensation insurance,
- the employer has decided to self-insure for workers’ compensation,
- you do not fall within the employer’s workers’ compensation coverage, often because you are an independent contractor or a subcontractor, or
- the employer is violating state law by not carrying coverage.
If the employer does not provide workers’ compensation coverage, then the employer cannot claim that the state’s workers’ compensation act is the exclusive remedy available for you.
What is a third-party claim?
A third-party claim is a personal injury lawsuit against someone who hurt you on your worksite. The defendant in these cases is not your employer, though. It is often:
- your coworker or supervisor,
- a customer or client of the employer,
- the property owner where the worksite is located, or
- one of the employer’s vendors.
These lawsuits demand compensation from one of these people when they were the ones responsible for your work-related injuries, even though the accident happened on the job.
Will I still receive workers’ compensation benefits?
Generally, you still receive workers’ compensation benefits if you sue your employer or a third party. However, if you receive a settlement or verdict in the personal injury case, many states require you to pay back an equal amount of workers’ comp benefits. This is to prevent you from receiving a windfall.
What is the law in California?
In California, the general rule is that workers’ compensation is the exclusive remedy for workplace injuries.11
However, California lets you sue your employer if the injury:
- was caused by a willful physical assault by the employer,
- was aggravated by fraudulent concealment,
- was caused by a product that was defectively manufactured by the employer and was sold, leased, or bought by a third party for your subsequent use, or
- would not be covered by workers’ compensation law.12
In any other circumstance, workers’ compensation continues to be your exclusive remedy.
California does not recognize the full dual capacity doctrine.
While California was the first state to let employees sue their employer for injuries caused outside the line of work,13 that court case has since been legislatively overturned with the passage of California Labor Code section 3602. It now only allows for lawsuits where the employer’s dual capacity was as the maker of a defective product.14
However, some California courts have stretched the meaning of injuries that are not covered by workers’ compensation to include some instances that are close to dual capacity cases. In particular, courts have let claims based on premises liability move forward.15
Third party claims
You can also sue coworkers in a third party claim for injuries or fatalities caused by the coworker’s:
- willful and unprovoked physical act of aggression, or
- intoxication.16
If you do pursue a personal injury claim against your employer and receive a settlement or judgment, any workers’ compensation benefits already paid will be credited towards that award.17
You can sue your employer if they willfully harmed you.
Legal References:
- See, for example, Deutsch v. Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co., Inc., 452 N.Y.S.2d 469 (1982).
- See, for example, California Labor Code 4558 LAB.
- See, for example, Mandolidis v. Elkins Industries, Inc., 246 S.E.2d 907 (W.Va. 1978) and West Virginia Code Annotated 23-4-2(d)(2)(A)-(B)(ii).
- Reed Tool Co. v. Copelin, 689 S.W.2d 404 (Tex. 1985).
- See Figueroa v. Delant Construction Co., 118 So.3d 272 (Fla Dist. Ct. App. 2013).
- See, for example, Birklid v. Boeing Co., 127 Wash.2d 853 (1995) and Schwindt v. Hershey Foods Corp., 81 P.3d 1144 (Colo. App. 2003).
- Facts from Delamotte v. Unitcase Division of Midland Ross Corp., 411 N.E.2d 814 (Ohio Ct. App. 1978).
- Facts from Duprey v. Shane, 39 Cal.2d 781 (1952).
- See, for example, California Labor Code 3602 LAB.
- Longever v. Revere Copper & Brass, Inc., 408 N.E.2d 857 (Mass. 1980).
- California Labor Code 3600 LAB.
- California Labor Code 3602(b)-(c) LAB.
- Duprey v. Shane, 39 Cal.2d 781 (1952).
- California Labor Code 3602(b)(3) LAB.
- See Weinstein v. St. Mary’s Medical Center, 58 Cal.App.4th 1223 (1997) (victim of work injury went to the hospital where she worked for medical treatment, slipped, and fell) and Miller v. King, 19 Cal.App.4th 1732 (1993) (victim slipped and fell on the job and sued property owners, who happened to be shareholders in the employer’s corporation).
- California Labor Code 3601(a) LAB.
- California Labor Code 3600(b) LAB.
About the Author
Neil Shouse
A former Los Angeles prosecutor, attorney Neil Shouse graduated with honors from UC Berkeley and Harvard Law School (and completed additional graduate studies at MIT). He has been featured on CNN, Good Morning America, Dr Phil, The Today Show and Court TV. Mr Shouse has been recognized by the National Trial Lawyers as one of the Top 100 Criminal and Top 100 Civil Attorneys.