Surgical Stapler Lawsuits

Updated

Surgical staples lawsuits — How to file a claim

Surgical stapling lawsuits are mass tort claims against doctors, hospitals, and device-makers seeking compensation for the injuries that happen after a surgical stapling procedure has gone wrong. Staples are increasingly being used during surgeries as an alternative to stitches or sutures. But the staplers that surgeons use can misfire during a procedure, leading to serious injuries and medical complications. The frequency of these misfires has likely been underreported for years, prompting the FDA to consider taking action. More info at https://www.shouselaw.com/torts/stapler


Surgical stapler lawsuits
are mass tort claims by victims against the device manufacturers. Plaintiffs allege a design defect caused the staplers to misfire. And this malfunction caused their organ damage and other complications.

The frequency of surgical stapler misfires has been under-reported for years. Only recently the FDA made public the thousands of non-fatal incident reports. And hundreds of others died from their injuries.

Shouse Law Group is helping surgical stapler victims sue the device-makers. We are pursuing substantial financial compensation to pay for doctor's bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

The statute of limitations to file suit is not long. So victims are advised to consult with an attorney soon.

In this article, our surgical stapler lawyers explain:

Doctor using a surgical stapler. Many malfunction. This may lead to a lawsuit against the stapler-maker.
Surgeons may use staples as an alternative to stitches or sutures.

1. What are surgical staplers and staples? Who makes them?

Surgeons use surgical staplers to close wounds or incisions. Staples are an alternative to sutures and stitches. And they work more quickly and with less inflammation.

There are many types of staples:

  • Plastic - for patients with metal allergies.
  • Polymer - used in plastic surgeries to reduce scarring.
  • Dissolvable - preventing the need for a second surgery to remove them.
  • Titanium - which does not affect MRI scans.
  • Circular - for specific operations, like esophagogastric surgery.

There are also several types of surgical staplers: Disposable, reusable, large, and small. Companies that manufacturer surgical staplers and staples include:

2. Are surgical staples safe? What injuries do they cause?

Surgical stapling carries numerous risks. Risks that are not present with sutures or stitches.

Four problems associated with staples include: 

  1. The staple can break during placement. Or at some point afterwards.
  2. The staple can cause an allergic reaction in the patient.
  3. Bacteria on the staple can cause an infection at the incision site.
  4. Metal or plastic from the staple can leach into the bloodstream.

Four problems associated with staplers include: 

  1. The stapler can jam during the procedure. The surgical staff then scramble for other tissue-binding methods. This may cause blood loss. And while the incision is open, infection risks increase.
  2. The stapler can fire with too much or too little force. This causes damage to the tissue. Or it fails to close the incision.
  3. The stapler can fire inaccurately. This sends a staple into the wrong place. This can cause serious complications.
  4. The stapler can fire accidentally. This may create an unforeseen medical condition.

All this may cause new wounds. And it may prevent wounds from healing correctly. Just some injuries caused by defective staples include:

  • Excessive bleeding,
  • Cardiac arrest from blood loss,
  • Sepsis,
  • Fistula formation, and
  • Tearing and damage to internal tissues and even organs
  • Permanently damaged digestive systems
  • Need for permanent ostomy bags
  • Corrective surgeries

In some cases, surgical staples cause fatal complications.

3. Have there been recalls?

Yes. Recent surgical stapler and staple recalls include:

Year

Manufacturer

Stapler / Staple

2019

Ethicon

Endo-Surgery Curved Intraluminal Stapler with Adjustable Height Staples (and endoscopic)

2019

Medtronic

Endo GIA Articulating Reloads with TriStaple Technology

2018

Medtronic

Endo GIA “Auto Suture” Universal Articulating Loading Unit

2015

Ethicon

Endopath Echelon Flex Powered Vascular Staplers

2013

Ethicon

ECHELON 60mm Endoscopic Linear Cutter Reloads

Some reasons for the recalls are:

  • Missing components
  • Bad alignment
  • Misfirings
  • Reload problems
  • Other defects

For a full list of recalled devices, visit the FDA stapler recall page.

A "recall" sign. Various models of surgical staples and staplers have been recalled due to defects.
More than 200 surgical staplers and related devices have been recalled.

4. How does the FDA monitor the safety of surgical staplers?

The FDA regulates surgical staplers as Class I medical devices. Class I devices are supposed to have minimal potential harm. And their design should be simple.1 Other examples of Class 1 devices include:

  • Elastic bandages,
  • Latex gloves,
  • Tongue depressors, and
  • Bedpans

Class I devices are exempt from many FDA regulations. This includes the mandatory reporting of malfunctions and injuries. Therefore, non-fatal surgical stapler malfunctions are not on MAUDE. This stands for Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience. MAUDE is a public database that tracks medical device failures.

Medical providers rely on MAUDE for safety data. They use it to make informed decisions about medical devices. But the only data on MAUDE for surgical staplers involve fatalities. This is a tiny fraction of the total number of incidents.

Instead, non-fatal incident reports went to ASRP. This is short for Alternative Summary Reporting Program. This FDA database was not accessible to the public until June 2019. (It can now be accessed here.)2

Surgical stapler companies took advantage of the Class 1 classification. They could hide evidence of the stapler-caused-injuries. They could report non-fatal incidents to ASRP instead of MAUDE.3 It took doctors a while to catch on. Many surgeons became suspicious of the low numbers on MAUDE.4

The number of surgical stapling incidents submitted to ASRP was high. Finally, the FDA issued a letter to health care providers warning them of the danger.5 From 2011 through March 31, 2018, there had been more than 32,000 stapling malfunctions. These caused:

  • 366 deaths, and
  • More than 9,000 serious injuries

Many of these injuries and fatalities resulted from a defective stapler.6

The FDA said it would reconsider its Class I classification of surgical staplers.7 It also issued draft guidance for surgical stapling companies.8

Attorneys working on surgical staple lawsuit against the medical manufacturer.
Many victims have brought defective design lawsuits against surgical staple manufacturers.

5. What are the grounds for a lawsuit? Are they individual or collective?

Victims can bring a defective design claim against the surgical stapler manufacturer. Plaintiffs would need to prove:

  1. The device's defective design posed a foreseeable risk, and
  2. The device was manufactured and used as it was supposed to be

Manufacturers try to pin all blame on the surgeon. They claim the surgeon was negligent. Not that the device was faulty.

Nevertheless, many lawsuits led to sizeable trial verdicts. In 2015, Ethicon was ordered to pay $80 million to a surgical staple victim. That included $70 million in punitive damages. The victim had nearly died from complications. Her anal canal was sealed shut by a defective stapler. The stapler model was subsequently recalled.9

So far, all surgical staple lawsuits have been individual. No class actions or multi-district litigations (MDL) have formed. But this may change.

6. What money damages can surgical stapling victims recover?

Plaintiffs' attorneys pursue settlements that cover all compensatory damages. These are costs and losses the injuries caused. Examples include:

  • Past and future medical expenses,
  • Lost wages,
  • Future inability to earn a living, and
  • Pain and suffering (often the highest cost)

Most cases resolve through negotiation. But if a case goes to trial, plaintiffs' attorneys would also fight for punitive damages. These are meant to punish defendants for wrongful conduct. Such as refusing to recall a dangerous surgical stapler. And punitive damages are often greater than compensatory damages.

Contact us for help...

Receptionists for our surgical stapler attorneys
Call us for help at (855) LAW-FIRM.

Are you the victim of surgical staples gone wrong? Call our mass tort attorneys at 855-LAWFIRM. Or fill out the form on this page. We will fight for the largest settlement possible. And you pay nothing unless we win.


Legal References:

  1. See Medical Device Regulation Act.

  2. See Christina Jewett, “Hidden FDA Reports Detail Harm Caused By Scores Of Medical Devices,” Kaiser Health News (March 7, 2019).

  3. Id.

  4. See Kwazneski D, Six C, Stahlfeld K, “The unacknowledged incidence of laparoscopic stapler malfunction,” Surgical Endoscopy 27(1):86-9 (January 2013).

  5. FDA, “Safe Use of Surgical Staplers and Staples – Letter to Health Care Providers,” (March 8, 2019).

  6. Id. (“The FDA believes that many of the problems identified in these reports can be primarily attributed to surgical staplers for internal use because proper staple formation is largely contingent on proper function and use of the stapler.”)

  7. Id.

  8. FDA, “Surgical Staplers and Staples for Internal Use – Labeling Recommendations,” (April 23, 2019).

  9. Evan Sernoffsky, “Retired San Jose officer awarded $80 million over botched surgery,” SFGate (December 16, 2015).

Free attorney consultations...

The attorneys at Shouse Law Group bring more than 100 years collective experience fighting for individuals. We're ready to fight for you. Call us 24 hours a day, 365 days a year at 855-LAW-FIRM for a free case evaluation.

Regain peace of mind...

Shouse Law Defense Group has multiple locations throughout California. Click Office Locations to find out which office is right for you.

Office Locations

Shouse Law Group has multiple locations all across California, Nevada, and Colorado. Click Office Locations to find out which office is right for you.

Call us 24/7 (855) 396-0370