CRS 18-4-409 – Aggravated Motor Vehicle (Auto) Theft in Colorado

Aggravated motor vehicle (auto) theft in Colorado is when a person “knowingly obtains or exercises control over the motor vehicle of another without authorization or by threat or deception.”

Under CRS 18-4-409, sentencing can range from 6 months in jail to 12 years in state prison.

Definition

There are two degrees of aggravated auto theft. First-degree is more serious. Second-degree is less serious.

First-degree aggravated auto theft occurs if the defendant both steals the car and either:

1. Keeps the vehicle for more than a day or takes it out of Colorado for more than half a day;
2. Use the vehicle to commit a crime, injure someone with it, or cause more than $500 worth of damage with it; or
3. Attempts to alter or disguise the vehicle, VIN, or license plates

Second-degree aggravated auto theft is stealing a car without the above three factors.

Penalties

First-degree aggravated automobile theft is always a felony. Depending on the value of the vehicle and the defendant’s criminal history, penalties include:

• 1 – 12 years in Colorado State Prison, and/or
• $1,000 – $750,000 in fines

Second-degree aggravated automobile theft is almost always a felony. Depending on the value of the vehicle, penalties include:

• 1 – 3 years in prison, and/or
• $1,000 – $100,000 in fines

Second-degree aggravated automobile theft is a misdemeanor only when:

1. The vehicle is worth less than $2,000, and
2. The defendant has no more than one prior auto-theft conviction

The misdemeanor penalties are:

• Up to 364 days in jail, and/or
• Up to $1,000 in fines

Defenses

There are many potential defenses to aggravated motor vehicle theft criminal charges. Three examples include:

• The defendant owned the car;
• The defendant believed he/she had permission to take the car; or
• The police committed misconduct

Below our Denver Colorado criminal defense lawyers discuss:

• 1. How does Colorado law define aggravated motor vehicle theft?
  • 1.1. First-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft
  • 1.2. Second-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft
• 2. What are the penalties under CRS 18-4-409?
• 3. What are common defenses to auto theft?
• 4. Can the criminal record be sealed?
• 5. Related Colorado offenses
• 6. Recent auto theft statistics

1. How does Colorado law define aggravated motor vehicle theft?

Aggravated auto theft in Colorado occurs when a person knowingly steals another person’s or company’s vehicle. It does not matter whether the alleged thief

• uses threats or deception to obtain it or
• simply takes it without permission.

As discussed below, aggravated theft of a motor vehicle can be first- or second-degree depending on the severity of the case.

In some states, the crime of aggravated motor vehicle theft is known as grand theft auto. But in Colorado, it is always referred to as aggravated motor vehicle theft.

Additionally, if a car is stolen in one jurisdiction but recovered in another, the defendant may be prosecuted in:

• The jurisdiction where the theft occurred;
• Any jurisdiction through which the automobile was operated or transported; or
• The jurisdiction in which the automobile was recovered

Note that aggravated motor vehicle theft – like many crimes – requires both

• a mens rea (culpable mental state) and
• an actus reus (an action).

In this case, the mens rea is knowing, and the actus reus is taking the car without authorization or by threats or deception.¹

1.1. First-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft

First-degree aggravated auto theft has two elements:

1. The defendant knowingly obtains or exercises control over another’s motor vehicle without authorization or by threat or deception; AND
2. The defendant either:

• Retains possession or control of the vehicle for more than 24 hours; or
• Attempts to or does alter or disguise the appearance of the motor vehicle; or
• Attempts to or does remove or alter the vehicle identification number (VIN); or
• Uses the motor vehicle in the commission of a crime other than a traffic offense; or
• Causes $500 or more worth of property damage; or
• Causes bodily injury to another person; or
• Removes the vehicle from the state of Colorado for more than 12 hours; or
• Unlawfully attaches or displays license plates other than those officially issued for the vehicle²

The “knowingly” element applies to both the defendant’s physical control over the automobile as well as his/her awareness that he/she is acting without authorization from the owner. And all that matters is what the defendant subjectively knew, not what a reasonable person would objectively know under the defendant’s circumstances.

Meanwhile, “without authorization” means “that the owner of the property, or a person in possession of the property with the owner’s consent, has not given the actor permission to exercise control over the property.”³

Examples of first-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft include:

• Stealing a car and selling it;
• Borrowing a car without permission and getting into a wreck;
• Driving one’s parents’ car without permission and seriously injuring a pedestrian;
• Stealing a car and using it as a getaway car; or
• Committing a carjacking and taking the vehicle to another state to sell it

See our articles on theft of motor vehicle parts (CRS 42-5-104), operating a chop shop (CRS 18-4-420(1)), and tampering with a vehicle (CRS 42-5-103).

1.2. Second-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft

Second-degree aggravated auto theft is knowingly obtaining or exercising control over another’s motor vehicle without authorization or by threat or deception. Plus none of the factors in the above subsection apply.⁴

Examples of second-degree aggravated motor vehicle theft include:

• Being a valet or parking attendant and driving the car around town without permission;
• Borrowing someone else’s car without permission for a joyride and returning it the next day;
• Using one’s parents’ car without permission to go on a date; or
• Temporarily refusing to give back a car that has been temporarily entrusted to his or her care

2. What are the penalties under CRS 18-4-409?

The punishments for aggravated motor vehicle theft depend on the value of the motor vehicle and the defendant’s past criminal record (if any).

Aggravated Vehicle Theft (CRS 18-4-409)	Colorado penalties (based on the value of the stolen vehicle)*
First-degree	Less than $20,000 Class 5 felony: 1 – 3 years in prison (with 2 years of mandatory parole), and/or $1,000 – $100,000
	$20,000 to less than $100,000 Class 4 felony 2 – 6 years in prison (with 3 years of mandatory parole), and/or $2,000 – $500,000
	$100,000 or higher Class 3 felony: 4 – 12 years in prison (with 5 years of mandatory parole), and/or $3,000 – $750,000
	Third auto theft conviction (any value) Class 3 felony 4 – 12 years in prison (with 5 years of mandatory parole), and/or $3,000 – $750,000
Second-degree	$20,000 or higher Class 5 felony: 1 – 3 years in prison (with 2 years of mandatory parole), and/or $1,000 – $100,000
	$2,000 to less than $20,000 Class 6 felony: 1 – 1 ½ years in prison (with 1 year of mandatory parole), and/or $1,000 – $100,000
	Less than $2,000 Class 1 misdemeanor: Up to 364 days in jail, and/or Up to $1,000 5

See our related article, When is theft charged as a felony in Colorado?

3. What are common defenses to auto theft?

Seven defenses that may get Colorado aggravated auto theft charges completely dropped include:

1. The vehicle belonged to the defendant;
2. Someone else took the vehicle;
3. The defendant had permission to drive the vehicle (shown by testimony, emails, etc.);
4. The defendant did not know he/she lacked the owner’s permission to borrow the car (“mistake of fact”);
5. The car owner falsely accused the defendant;
6. The police entrapped the defendant, who was not predisposed to car theft. Therefore, the defendant never would have stolen the car but for the police’s pressure; or
7. The police discovered the car through an illegal search and seizure

Note that it is an affirmative defense that the defendant had a good faith belief that she/she could have the car. This means that the defendant admits to possessing the car. But the possession was justified and therefore not a crime.

Meanwhile, five defenses that may get a first-degree auto theft charge lessened to a second-degree charge are that:

• The defendant did not keep the vehicle for more than 24 hours and did not take it out of state for more than 12 hours;
• No one was injured;
• The defendant did not alter the vehicle in any way;
• The vehicle was not used to commit a crime; or
• Any damage costs less than $500 to repair⁶

4. Can the criminal record be sealed?

Yes, unless the conviction was for a class 3 felony (first-degree aggravated car theft of $100,000 or higher). Otherwise, a CRS 18-4-409 conviction is sealable three years after the case ends.

Note that any cases that get dismissed (meaning there is no conviction) can be sealed right away.⁷

Learn how to petition for a Colorado record seal.

(Note that record seals are very similar to expungements. Currently, only juvenile cases and underage DUI cases can be expunged.)

5. Related Colorado offenses

5.1. Theft of Motor Vehicle Parts

Like it sounds, theft of motor vehicle parts (CRS 42-5-104) is

• removing,
• detaching, or
• taking any part from

an automobile with criminal intent.

It can be a misdemeanor or a felony depending on the items stolen.

5.2. Felony Grand Theft

Felony grand theft (CRS 18-4-401(2)) is intentionally taking another person’s property, which is valued at $2,000 or higher. The extent of the fines and prison time depends on the value of the items stolen.

5.3. Theft by Receiving Stolen Property

Receiving stolen property (CRS 18-4-404) is knowingly obtaining control over items that have been stolen. It is punished the same as theft: It can be a

• petty offense,
• misdemeanor, or
• felony

depending on the value of the stolen items that the defendant received.

6. Recent auto theft statistics

Colorado ranks number one in the nation for auto theft.

In the first six months of 2022 alone, Colorado has had nearly 48,100 vehicles stolen. (This number includes so-called “puffer thefts,” which are cars stolen while they are left running an unattended.)

The Colorado cities with the most car thefts in order are:

1. Denver
2. Aurora
3. Westminster
4. Pueblo

In Denver, the neighborhoods with the most car thefts in order are:

1. DIA
2. Central Park
3. Five Points
4. Northeast Park Hill

Auto thefts often accompany other “secondary crimes.” So far in 2022, these secondary crimes include:

• 9,670 property crimes
• 1,730 drug crimes
• 292 violent crimes

The majority of the vehicle stolen were valued at $5,000 to less than $25,000. As for the suspected car thieves, about 42.5% of them were between 25 and 34 years old.⁸

Arrested in Colorado on a theft crime? Contact our Denver criminal defense lawyers. Our criminal law firm will fight to get the charges reduced or dismissed.

We defend clients throughout the state, including Denver, Greeley, Colorado Springs, Aurora, Lakewood, Jefferson County, Douglas County, Boulder, Adams County, Arapahoe County, and more.

Simply fill out the confidential form on this page. Or call us.

Colorado Legal Defense Group
4047 Tejon Street
Denver, CO 80211

In California? See our article on grand theft auto law (PC 487d1).

In Nevada? See our article on grand larceny of a motor vehicle (NRS 205.228).

---

Legal references: