Getting arrested for DUI does not mean you will be convicted. Police misconduct, defective breathalyzers and crime lab mistakes may be enough to get your charges lessened or dismissed. Visit our page on Colorado DUI Laws to learn more.
Criminal Defense » How does the "exclusionary rule" apply in Colorado?
The “exclusionary rule” allows judges in criminal cases to disregard (“exclude”) evidence that has been illegally obtained by police.
Police are required to adhere to the Fourth Amendment‘s prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures when conducting searches. In general, police are required to secure a Colorado search warrant prior to executing a search.
In order for these search warrants to be valid, they must indicate with specificity the locations to be searched and the items to be seized, and they must be supported with probable cause that a crime has taken place. Unsupported, vague, or overbroad search warrants can be voided as unconstitutional.
Even if a search warrant is valid, police may not go beyond the bounds of the warrant (with some exceptions). Police who do not have a legal reason to search and seize property outside the bounds of the warrant are violating the Fourth Amendment.
Meanwhile, police searches done without a warrant are usually unlawful unless the circumstances fall under a legal exception, such as:
In short, police must respect people’s reasonable expectation of privacy and may not execute searches without meeting Fourth Amendment prerequisites.
When a person is charged with a crime, the defense attorney will investigate whether the evidence against the defendant was lawfully obtained through a legal search. If any evidence may have been procured in contravention of the Fourth Amendment, the defense attorney would file a motion to suppress evidence with the court.
The theory behind motions to suppress is that any evidence that is found through an unlawful search is tainted. Therefore, it is only fair for this unlawfully-obtained evidence to be inadmissible (“suppressed”) at trial.
Note that the exclusionary rule applies not only to the original evidence that was illegally-obtained but also to any new evidence that that illegally-obtained evidence lead police to (“the fruit of the poisonous tree”).
There are some exceptions to the exclusionary rule where evidence that was illegally obtained could still be admitted at trial:
Colorado courts typically hold hearings to decide whether or not to admit evidence that may have been illegally obtained. The prosecution presents evidence arguing why the evidence should be admitted, and the defense attorney argues why the evidence should be suppressed. If the judge decides to suppress the evidence, the prosecution may be left with insufficient evidence to win a guilty verdict at trial.
Michael Becker has over a quarter-century's worth of experience as an attorney and more than 100 trials under his belt. He is a sought-after legal commentator and is licensed to practice law in Colorado, Nevada, California, and Florida.
According to the White House, Nevada’s drug overdose rate far exceeds the national average and is the fourth highest in the nation. Many people in Las Vegas who die from a drug overdose could have survived if they had received medical attention immediately. That’s why Nevada passed a new law in 2015 that shields individuals ...
It can be. There are times when defendants in criminal cases may want to waive their right to a jury trial, and instead have a bench trial where the judge alone decides guilt or lack of guilt. Examples of when a defendant may want to waive a trial by jury include when: the defendant is ...
Depositions are rarely admitted as evidence in Nevada criminal trials. But judges potentially permit them under the following five circumstances: The witness has passed away after giving the deposition; The witness is no longer of sound mind after giving the deposition; The witness has an illness or injury which prevents him/her from attending the trial ...
What Happens if You Get a Probation Violation in a DUI Case? If people violate a term of their probation in a DUI case, a probation officer or police officer can take them into custody pending a probation violation hearing. At the hearing, the judge has the discretion to reinstate the probation, modify the probation ...